Skip content

See the forest through the trees

Anthony F. Pappas Forestry Practice Lead at EcoEngineers, an LRQA company

On COP31’s Nature and Land Use Day, professional certified forester Anthony F. Pappas, Forestry Practice Lead at EcoEngineers, an LRQA company, explains why forest carbon projects deliver far more than carbon management, and why the market should also start measuring and valuing those benefits.

 

COP31 turns to nature and land use today, and forests will feature in almost every conversation. Most of those conversations will focus on tonnes of carbon. As a forester, I’d encourage everyone to look further, because a well-managed forest can sequester and store carbon while also providing significant benefits for wildlife, water quality, and rural economies.  

Good forestry is rarely about optimizing a single outcome. The most resilient forests are often those managed to balance carbon storage, timber production, wildlife habitat and water quality over the long term. Unfortunately, most of that extra value goes uncounted. 

A working forest 

Consider a typical improved forest management project in which a landowner, often an investment firm, enrolls a large tract of working timberland in a carbon project registered under an improved forest management standard. The land can and often does remain a working forest. Timber harvesting continues as a landowner’s source of income, supporting local loggers and sawmills. What changes is the management objective. Sustainable forest management goals are incorporated alongside traditional timber production objectives. 

With long-term carbon objectives now part of the plan, the landowner may encourage trees to grow for longer rotations and adapt their harvest strategy accordingly, so the forest stores more carbon over time. Credits are intended to represent additional carbon stored beyond a business-as-usual baseline, based on forest inventories and growth modeling. Those assessments are subject to third-party validation and verification under accredited carbon standards. 

Done well, targeted management also makes the forest a better home for wildlife. Imagine a mature oak-hickory forest with a dense, closed canopy and little understory vegetation, where you can see 200 yards through the trees. It may look tidy, but for wildlife it can provide relatively poor habitat for many species, with nothing to eat and nowhere to hide.  

Prescriptive, sustainable timber harvesting changes that by opening gaps in the canopy in many forest types. Sunlight reaches the forest floor, and berries, ferns and flowering plants grow back to feed pollinators, songbirds and other wildlife. Along streams, wider buffers of trees keep the water cool for native trout. In the Appalachian forests I know best, these practices can support habitat for species such as the cerulean warbler and the endangered Indiana bat. 

Every forest is different 

Yet forest carbon is often priced as if every acre were the same. Two neighbouring properties can earn the same rate per credit, even when one protects rare habitat while the other contains comparatively low ecological value. Buyers of the first are supporting far more than carbon, and the price should reflect it. 

We already have the tools to measure the difference. Acoustic monitoring can record which bird species use a property, and that data can be collected alongside the forest inventory projects already carried out. Biodiversity data could then support a premium on the carbon price, rewarding landowners for the full value of their forests. The science largely exists today. What remains difficult is standardizing measurements, verifying outcomes at scale and creating markets that consistently reward those benefits. 

The same principle applies to methods. Forests around the world face very different pressures, from wildfire in overstocked western US forests to clearing for cattle in the Amazon. Methodologies built for each region, with baselines updated as conditions change, can improve confidence that credits reflect local conditions and risks. 

Walk the forest 

Part of the challenge is that forestry has rarely explained itself well. Foresters and loggers do different jobs: loggers harvest timber, while foresters manage the whole forest, often with professional credentials. Sustainable harvesting by a logger under a forester’s management plan can support climate, wildlife and rural economies simultaneously when management objectives are balanced appropriately. 

That’s why my advice to anyone buying forest carbon credits is to go and see the project. Spend a day with a forester, listen for the birds and look at the streams and habitat for yourself. You’ll understand far more about what you’re supporting than any spreadsheet can show you.  

In fact, reach out to EcoEngineers – we’ll take you along with us next time in the woods!